Monday, August 29, 2011

Please comment on my literature research essay on Shakespeare's women. The ladies I want to use are Lady Macbeth and Juliet.Thesis: Women are...

This is an interesting concept, to look at two realms of
life in several works; and political and social realms do seem to be a useful pairing,
as well.  When I look at your two female examples, though, I have to wonder what issues
you'll use.  Lady Macbeth in Macbeth is certainly more a part of
the politics of the play than Juliet in Romeo and Juliet
is.


Lady Macbeth is an equal partner with her
husband; she convinces him to do what he is at least somewhat hesitant to do (murder
Duncan) in an attempt to claim the crown.  She greets Duncan graciously (despite her
intention to ensure he does not leave her house alive); she tries to appease all the
lords at the banquet when Macbeth is seeing Banquo's ghost and is acting crazy (so their
murderous ways are not discovered).  Even in her social duties, Lady Macbeth is still
aware of the political ramifications.  In short, Lady Macbeth is not particularly
relegated to a mere social presence nor is she excluded from the political realm in
deference to her husband.


Juliet, on the other hand, has
little experience in either realm. She has agreed to "look" at the young man her father
has chosen, presumably a good match for the family; later she agrees to marry him
(though she has much different intentions); she seems relatively uninvolved in the
politics of the feud, though she is most certainly aware of it.  In the social realm,
she attends her father's yearly party and she is a participant in the social rite of
marriage.  In short, Juliet is not overtly a part of the politics of the family
feud, but she is involved in several social moments in the
play.


Perhaps what makes this more difficult is that Juliet
is so young and Lady Macbeth is so, well, experienced.  I'm not sure which Shakespearean
characters you're familiar with, but maybe Gertrude in Hamlet, a
relatively familiar play, might be more comparable to Lady Macbeth simply because she
has lived and experienced a little more life.  I still wonder if you'll find that there
is a dichotomy (a division) between the political and social roles in Shakespeare, but
with these two at least you'd have a similar comparison.  Best of
luck!

No comments:

Post a Comment

How is Anne's goal of wanting "to go on living even after my death" fulfilled in Anne Frank: The Diary of a Young Girl?I didn't get how it was...

I think you are right! I don't believe that many of the Jews who were herded into the concentration camps actually understood the eno...