Sunday, September 9, 2012

How does Shakespeare solve the problems of appearance and reality in the play Much Ado About Nothing?

In Much Ado About Nothing,
Shakespeare shows that the duality between appearance versus reality is a matter of
gender, social class, age, and status.


In terms of gender,
Beatrice appears to scorn all men, and Benedict appears to scorn all women.  But, with
carefully crafted "lies," their friends convince them that "love" destroys all scorn.
 Or, one could say that Beatrice had always secretly loved Benedick but only appeared to
hate him to save face and defend herself as an old maid.


In
terms of social class, Dogberry appears to be a blathering idiot, but in reality he is
more vigilant in his duty than the Prince and his entourage.  He and his watchmen
discover the plot against Hero and save the day, not with words (appearances), but with
actions (reality).


In terms of age, Leonato and Benedick
show the young Claudio the meaning of honor as they defend Hero and Beatrice
respectively.  Even though he is an old man, Leonato challenges Claudio because he knows
that his daughter is honorable.  So too does Benedick, at the bequest of Beatrice,
challenge Claudio.  Each man shows that women's actions (reality) far outweigh what men
say (appearances) about them.


In terms of status, Don John
takes advantage of the naive Prince and Claudio.  He appears to be an honorable man by
showing that women are deceivers.  This confirms what most men wanted to believe, and so
the Prince and Claudio fall prey to Don John's words and the appearance of promiscuity
(by Hero's gentlewoman).  Even though Don John is a bastard, an illegitimate son who is
not to be trusted, the other males place more stock in his reputation than that of the
otherwise pure Hero.


All in all, words are used to uphold
the appearances of male status, reputation, and sexist double-standards instead of the
reality of a world in which women, old men, and lower classes may indeed be
honorable.

No comments:

Post a Comment

How is Anne's goal of wanting "to go on living even after my death" fulfilled in Anne Frank: The Diary of a Young Girl?I didn't get how it was...

I think you are right! I don't believe that many of the Jews who were herded into the concentration camps actually understood the eno...