Thursday, June 25, 2015

Antigone was a stubborn young woman. What are at least three choices Antigone could have made to avoid her tragic death. Details/examples to...

The simple answer is to back down.  In the end, this is what
Antigone could have done in a variety of situations and circumstances.  Antigone could have
adhered to the rule of law, as represented by Creon.  She could have made peace internally with
the idea that the law is there for a reason.  Perhaps, a permutation could have been to mourn
privately and acknowledge her brother's spirit without the need for a ceremony.  Antigone is
insistent that there is a public display of grief and honor for her brother.  Yet, if this is
transmitted privately, much of what happens could have been avoided.  At the same time, if
Antigone had placed a primacy on her relationship with Haemon, perhaps much of what happened
could be avoided.  She values the need to bury her brother more than her love with her fiancee. 
Antigone has more of a commitment to her past than her future with her fiancee.  Changing this
perspective could have been another choice made.  Finally, I think that understanding that her
sister has an equally valid claim and acknowledging that could have been another choice Antigone
could have made.  The way Antigone approaches Ismene is that she has cornered the market on
respecting her brother's wishes.  I think that understanding and validating Ismene's approach to
the funeral rites of her brother could have helped to avert what happened.  All of these
predicaments involve Antigone reducing the intensity in a situation fraught with
it.

No comments:

Post a Comment

How is Anne's goal of wanting "to go on living even after my death" fulfilled in Anne Frank: The Diary of a Young Girl?I didn't get how it was...

I think you are right! I don't believe that many of the Jews who were herded into the concentration camps actually understood the eno...