Friday, April 24, 2015

What is the most important element of fiction in this story?

If I had to choose one of the elements of fiction that was
the most important in "The Lesson," it would be point of
view
.


The story is told from Sylvia's viewpoint
and the story's focus, of course, is Miss Moore's lesson.  Had the story been told from
the third person, its impact on the reader would not be as powerful; we would not have
been able to follow the uneasy progression of Sylvia's thoughts.  With the first person
point of view, we know exactly how Sylvia
feels.


The group of students Miss Moore has chosen to try
to teach are either unaware, disinterested, or—as is the case with Sylvia—opposed to her
attempts.  Miss Moore is not trying to teach all these children a lesson; she is
speaking to an audience that does not welcome her intent.  The essence of "The Lesson"
is Miss Moore's hope to reach past the naiveté of someone (anyone)
in the group, and open his or her eyes to a more sophisticated view of the world of
which they are a part—and in doing so, motivate that person to take a personal interest
in his or her life, with positive results.


It is easy to
perceive through Sylvia's internal dialogue that she feels disdain and resentment about
most things.  She is an angry girl. If we could speak to Sylvia, she would probably know
some of the reasons why she is angry, but probably
not all.  It is to this second aspect of Sylvia's intellect that
Miss Moore's words find purchase, and take root.


Can we, as
the reader, know that Miss Moore is specifically speaking for the sake of reaching
Sylvia in particular?  There is no indication from Sylvia to support this kind of
conjecture, though we find out that Miss Moore is very quick to notice Sylvia's grasp of
the "lesson." Miss Moore probably throws her ideas out, like seeds, to see with which
youngster (if any) the ideas "find fertile ground" and start to
grow.


Sylvia is enlightened when she learns of the foolish
way people with money can spend it even while other people are struggling daily to make
ends meet.  As she processes this, we can almost see Sylvia wrinkling her forehead as
she tries to make sense of this seemingly nonsensical
"truth."


Sylvia was unaware (as were the other kids) that
this kind of store—and this kind of disparity between those who "have" and those who
"have not," existed. The unfairness of it jolts Sylvia's social awareness awake enough
to know that something is seriously wrong (though we can also tell that she would not
thank Miss Moore for providing Sylvia with this new
insight).


As Sylvia follows some distance behind Sugar at
the end, she has new food for thought.  As Sylvia tells it, Sugar momentarily seemed to
grasp the situation at the toy store, but then the "light went out" and she let the idea
go.  And although Sylvia does not seem to completely understand the
enormous significance of what she has learned, her awareness has
been tapped.  We can assume that she will never let go of this new world view, and will
never be the same person.  We are able to get a precise sense of Sylvia's state of mind
with the use of the first person point of view.

No comments:

Post a Comment

How is Anne's goal of wanting "to go on living even after my death" fulfilled in Anne Frank: The Diary of a Young Girl?I didn't get how it was...

I think you are right! I don't believe that many of the Jews who were herded into the concentration camps actually understood the eno...