Thursday, January 15, 2015

From Polonius' conversation with Laertes in Act 1 Scene 3 what kind of a life philosophy does Polonius seem to have?

If you look at the totality of Polonius's advice to
Laertes, it is pretty clear that Polonius is very concerned with outward appearances and
maintaining one's reputation.  Most of his advice is in reference to the appropriate
actions a man must take to keep himself from damaging his
reputation. 


1.The first few pieces of advice are
specifically about behavior.  He tells Laertes to "give thy thoughts no tongue."  He is
telling Laertes to keep his opinions and thoughts to himself so as not to offend anyone
or be misinterpreted by anyone.  He follows that up with, "nor any unproportion'd
thought his act."  He is telling him not to overreact to what others say. He follows
this theme a few lines later when he counsels Laertes to listen to everyone, but
reserve his comments and judgements.   He wants Leartes to be friendly, but not overly
so, until Laertes knows for sure they can be trusted -- only then should hold them "with
hoops of steel."


2. He warns him not be hot-headed and then
enter into quarrels, and be careful of what he might reveal if he is in
a fight. 


3. He next goes on about Laertes' outward
physical appearance, telling him to look nice, but not gaudy -- afterall, the clothes
are a first impression.


4. His last piece of advice is to
be careful with money -- lending to others often comes with more strife than it is worth
-- thus could create conflict.


Polonius sums up all of this
advice with a final thought: "This above all to thine own self be true."  If you only
look at that one line, then it could be regarded as a contradiction to everything he
says before it, but if you consider the complete sentence, he makes a logical point. 
The rest of thought is "And it must follow, as the night the day, thou canst not then be
false to any man."  What he means is that if you keep in mind all of the advice, and
think about your actions first, then you will not likely offend anyone else in the
process -- therefore you will be able to maintain you yourself and you
reputation.


In the end, the speech reveals a bit of
Polonius's skepticism about the nature of humanity -- assuming the negative about other
people's natures and motives, but Polonius has his position in the court by playing the
game correctly, so he is probably speaking from some truth of
experience.

No comments:

Post a Comment

How is Anne's goal of wanting "to go on living even after my death" fulfilled in Anne Frank: The Diary of a Young Girl?I didn't get how it was...

I think you are right! I don't believe that many of the Jews who were herded into the concentration camps actually understood the eno...